Talk:Komm, Jesu, komm, BWV 229 (Johann Sebastian Bach)

From ChoralWiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Errors in CPDL #9697

Score errors from http://www.chamberchorus.org/

m.4 Choir I, Sop. Underlay should be identical to ATB
m.20 Choir II, Bass First note should low C
m.27 Choir II, Bass First note should be E natural, not E flat
m.41 Choir II, Alto Text missing, should be "Frie-"
m.42 Choir I, Bass Underlay is wrong; first two notes should be sung to "dei-"
m.49 Choir II, Alto First word should be "Weg," not "wird"
m.73 Choir II, Bass Fourth note should be A flat, not A natural
m.74 Choir I, Alto A sharp should be A natural
m.110 Choir I, Sop. High F should be F natural
m.110 Choir II, Sop. High F should be F natural
m.145 Choir II, Tenor First note should be F, not D
m.159 Choir I, Tenor Underlay is wrong; remove "-ben"
m.160 Choir I, Tenor Underlay is wrong; "die" should be "-ben"
m.161 Choir I, Bass First note (tied) should be F, not E flat
m.188 Tutti Underlay is wrong; "Wil" should be "Weil"

NOTE: Advisory accidentals are not used in this edition; therefore, unless specifically indicated, the key signature governs each measure.

--Bobnotts talk 08:40, 18 January 2008 (PST)