Talk:Mass for Four Voices (William Byrd)

From ChoralWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

If the Fraser editions of Byrd - 4 were on the pre-WIKI CPDL site, should not list them under pre-WIKI CPDL ID numbers

Noel Stoutenburg 19:00, 2 May 2006 (PDT)


Spelling Errors in Credo (CPDL #00086)
30, T, "Lumun" --> Lumen"
62, T "caae-" --> "cae-"
153, ATB "unum" --> "unam"
170ff SATB "resurrexionem" --> resurrectionem (original spelling in the partbooks: resurrextionem)
Gerd Eichler 22:00, 30. December 2012 CET

Possible errors in the XML version by Gerd Eichler (submitted 2019-01-26)

When I open the XML version of the Mass for Four Voices by William Byrd, edited by Gerd Eichler (submitted 2019-01-26), using NMuseScore 4, I get an error message telling the file is corrupted, and supplying the details shown below.

The details of my Windows system and MuseScore version are: (Windows 10 Version 2009, Arch.: x86_64, MuseScore version (64-bit): 4.0.2-230651553, revision: github-musescore-musescore-dbe7c6d)

  • Incomplete measure: Full score, measure 458, staff 1. Found: 0/1. Expected: 5/2.
  • Incomplete measure: Full score, measure 459, staff 1. Found: 0/1. Expected: 11/4.
  • Incomplete measure: Full score, measure 460, staff 1. Found: 0/1. Expected: 5/2.
  • Incomplete measure: Full score, measure 461, staff 1. Found: 0/1. Expected: 5/2.
  • Incomplete measure: Full score, measure 462, staff 1. Found: 0/1. Expected: 5/2.
  • Incomplete measure: Full score, measure 462, staff 3. Found: 0/1. Expected: 5/2.
  • Incomplete measure: Full score, measure 463, staff 1. Found: 0/1. Expected: 5/2.
  • Incomplete measure: Full score, measure 463, staff 2. Found: 0/1. Expected: 5/2.
  • Incomplete measure: Full score, measure 463, staff 3. Found: 0/1. Expected: 5/2.
  • Incomplete measure: Full score, measure 464, staff 1. Found: 0/1. Expected: 5/2.
  • Incomplete measure: Full score, measure 464, staff 2. Found: 0/1. Expected: 5/2.
  • Incomplete measure: Full score, measure 464, staff 3. Found: 0/1. Expected: 5/2.
  • Incomplete measure: Full score, measure 465, staff 1. Found: 0/1. Expected: 2/2.
  • Incomplete measure: Full score, measure 465, staff 2. Found: 0/1. Expected: 2/2.
  • Incomplete measure: Full score, measure 465, staff 3. Found: 0/1. Expected: 2/2.

– User:Dovfa 14:52, 5 July 2023

For CPDL 53014, I can open either the mxl or capx files in MuseScore3; when I get the "Corrupted file" message, I choose "Ignore". The music appears normal throughout, even for the eight measures cited above. There are a few more pages than the pdf, and the layout seems different than the pdf. My recollection is that part of the format for mxl files has changed since these files were created; sometimes older mxl files are unreadable, but not in this case. (Please follow the instructions above, and sign your posts with four tildes (~~~~) at the end.) — Barry Johnston (talk) 15:46, 5 July 2023 (UTC)
Retrieved from "https://www.cpdl.org/wiki/index.php?title=Talk:Mass_for_Four_Voices_(William_Byrd)&oldid=1728697"