Talk:O sleep, fond fancy (John Bennet)

From ChoralWiki
Jump to: navigation, search

10154 & 10571
These two editions appear to be identical notewise.
1. C flat on last note of soprano should surely be B natural, though it makes no difference to the harmony.
2. Bars 43-44. The soprano notes on "thoughts molesting" appear to be a third down, at least according to the Denis Stevens edition (1966)
3. Bar 25. Soprano & alto have A on "with", whereas Stevens has G. G makes a passing discord, but it doesn't sound inauthentic.
4. Bar 54. Stevens has D in soprano, rather than B natural. B natural, with a tierce de Picardy, actually sounds better than the open chord.
Jamesgibb 10:46, 24 July 2011 (CDT)