Talk:To shorten Winter's sadness (Thomas Weelkes)

From ChoralWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
10213

Bar 13: Alto - Beat 4 on "To" should be G, as in first time through, not D.
Bar 18: Alto - Beat 4 on "la" should be G, as in first time through, not A.
Bar 22: Alto - F natural should probably be F sharp.
Bar 25: Soprano I and Soprano II notes on "la" are reversed. Should be B in Soprano I and G in Soprano II, to correspond to first time through.
Bar 32: F natural on "la" in Soprano I should probably be F sharp.
Bar 41: F natural on "la" in Soprano II should probably be F sharp.

11120

This edition has the same errors as 10213, of which it seems to be a copy.
Jamesgibb 03:20, 11 May 2012 (CDT)

Suggest the correction of bar 22 is debatable: F nat seems to work equally well if not better?
Simon_Shaw 22:10, 23 Jan 2023 (GMT)