User talk:Marghek

From ChoralWiki
(Redirected from User talk:Alan Knight)
Jump to: navigation, search

Preces and Responses

Hi Alan. I've just been tinkering with a couple of your pages and sorted out the category on Preces and Responses at Morning and Evening Prayer (Alan Knight). On the forums, you mentioned a category for preces and responses which does not appear on the drop down menu on the add works form. Unfortunately, that category was created after the add works form and the form hasn't been updated for years. Pages are manually edited if they have the wrong categories on them, like yours. If you have any more queries, feel free to ask on the forums as you have been doing or on my talk page. Regards --Bobnotts talk 08:35, 18 February 2008 (PST)

Stabat Mater (Agazzari)

I've checked back to my source, which is the 1864 Proske edition, rather than an original. I have transcribed it correctly according to Proske but, playing it back, I think this is an error in Proske and the Cs in both bars 14 and 15 of the Tenor should be sharpened, if only because the chord progression from 13-14 looks more likely that way. I'll alter my editions and upload new versions with the relevant notes marked as musica ficta, therefore.
I also think, on reflection, that bar 17 in the Soprano should be F sharp, not F, although again it is not indicated as such by Proske. So I'll make that change to my editions as well. If it were Gesualdo, rather than Aggazzari, I would be less confident!

Thanks for pointing this out, (a good example of why CPDL works so well!)
Jamesgibb (talk) 13:01, 15 October 2013 (UTC)