Talk:9 Advent-Motetten op. 176 (Josef Rheinberger)

From ChoralWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Minor errors

Thanks to both editors for the work they put in. Both editions seem to have the same musical errors:

  • number 2, bar 27 (Hold) = bar 73 (Hößl), soprano, first note: needs to be d
  • number 8, bar 22 (Hold) = bar 367 (Hößl), bass, first note: needs to be g#

-- pauljrossmann (talk) 00:03, 8 December 2022 (UTC)

Other minor errors:
  • number 8, bar 3 (Hold) = bar 348 (Hößl), soprano: the e on "invocantibus" needs to be f#
  • number 8, bar 19+20 (Hold) = bar 364+365 (Hößl), alto: not a melisma on "lu" but twice "alleluja"
    (according to Rheinberger's first manuscript, to be consulted at imslp.org)
  • number 8, bar 28 (Hold), soprano: the e on "invocantibus" needs to be f#
-- FerryMusic (talk) 20:48 12 January 2021