Talk:9 Advent-Motetten op. 176 (Josef Rheinberger): Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
FerryMusic (talk | contribs) |
(Put your comments in a separate post, please) |
||
| (5 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 4: | Line 4: | ||
*number 2, bar 27 (Hold) = bar 73 (Hößl), soprano, first note: needs to be d | *number 2, bar 27 (Hold) = bar 73 (Hößl), soprano, first note: needs to be d | ||
*number 8, bar 22 (Hold) = bar 367 (Hößl), bass, first note: needs to be g# | *number 8, bar 22 (Hold) = bar 367 (Hößl), bass, first note: needs to be g# | ||
--[[User:Pauljrossmann|pauljrossmann]] ([[User talk:Pauljrossmann|talk]]) 00:03, 8 December 2022 (UTC) | -- [[User:Pauljrossmann|pauljrossmann]] ([[User talk:Pauljrossmann|talk]]) 00:03, 8 December 2022 (UTC) | ||
: Other minor errors: | |||
:*number 8, bar 3 (Hold) = bar 348 (Hößl), soprano: the e on "invocan'''ti'''bus" needs to be f# | |||
:*number 8, bar 19+20 (Hold) = bar 364+365 (Hößl), alto: not a melisma on "lu" but twice "alleluja"<br>(according to Rheinberger's first manuscript, to be consulted at imslp.org) | |||
:*number 8, bar 28 (Hold), soprano: the e on "invocan'''ti'''bus" needs to be f# | |||
:-- [[User:Joost Veerman|FerryMusic]] ([[User talk:Joost Veerman|talk]]) 20:48 12 January 2021 | |||
Latest revision as of 04:11, 13 January 2023
Minor errors
Thanks to both editors for the work they put in. Both editions seem to have the same musical errors:
- number 2, bar 27 (Hold) = bar 73 (Hößl), soprano, first note: needs to be d
- number 8, bar 22 (Hold) = bar 367 (Hößl), bass, first note: needs to be g#
-- pauljrossmann (talk) 00:03, 8 December 2022 (UTC)
- Other minor errors:
- number 8, bar 3 (Hold) = bar 348 (Hößl), soprano: the e on "invocantibus" needs to be f#
- number 8, bar 19+20 (Hold) = bar 364+365 (Hößl), alto: not a melisma on "lu" but twice "alleluja"
(according to Rheinberger's first manuscript, to be consulted at imslp.org) - number 8, bar 28 (Hold), soprano: the e on "invocantibus" needs to be f#
- -- FerryMusic (talk) 20:48 12 January 2021