Talk:Dixit Dominus, HWV 232 (George Frideric Handel): Difference between revisions
mNo edit summary |
mNo edit summary |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
A comparison was made between this CPDL edition by Philip Legge (great work, Philip, thank you very much) and a commercial vocal score (Carus Verlag CV 55.232/05). The comparison was limited to the choral parts, without considering the lyrics. The following differences were identified (most of them, or even all, may be editorial). | A comparison was made between this CPDL edition by Philip Legge (great work, Philip, thank you very much) and a commercial vocal score (Carus Verlag CV 55.232/05). The comparison was limited to the choral parts, without considering the lyrics. The following differences were identified (most of them, or even all, may be editorial). | ||
:My score is based on Chrysander's edition, so I will note where there are discrepancies. | |||
'''Dixit Dominus''' | '''Dixit Dominus''' | ||
Bass, bar 21: the first note is D in Legge, B | Bass, bar 21: the first note is D in Legge, B{{flat}} in Carus. (Chrysander has B{{flat}}, so I will correct this.) | ||
Bass, bar 91: the last note is D in Legge, A in Carus. | Bass, bar 91: the last note is D in Legge/Chrysander, A in Carus. | ||
'''Juravit Dominus''' | '''Juravit Dominus''' | ||
Soprano I, bar 22: the first note is F natural in Legge, | Soprano I, bar 22: the first note is F natural in Legge/Chrysander, A{{flat}} in Carus. (Carus seems to be following the Violin 1 part verbatim.) | ||
Soprano I and Soprano II, bar 45 – 46: | Soprano I and Soprano II, bar 45 – 46: ties across barline missing in Legge. | ||
Tenor, bar 35: the last note is C in Legge, D in Carus. | Tenor, bar 35: the last note is C in Legge, D in Carus. (Chrysander definitely has C, but perhaps should have D as in Viola 2 part.) | ||
'''Tu es sacerdos''' | '''Tu es sacerdos''' | ||
Soprano II, bar 22: all notes are one third higher in Legge than in Carus. | Soprano II, bar 22: all notes are one third higher in Legge/Chrysander than in Carus. (Carus is following the Violin 2 part.) | ||
'''Dominus a dextris tuis''' | '''Dominus a dextris tuis''' | ||
Tenor, bar 93: the last note is B | Tenor, bar 93: the last note is B{{flat}} in Legge, F in Carus/Chrysander. | ||
Tenor, bar 124: the last note is E in Legge, A in Carus. | Tenor, bar 124: the last note is E in Legge/Chrysander, A in Carus. | ||
'''Judicabit''' | '''Judicabit''' | ||
Soprano I, bar 57 in Legge, 205 in Carus: the second note is C in Legge, B natural in Carus. | Soprano I, bar 57 in Legge, 205 in Carus: the second note is C in Legge/Chrysander, B natural in Carus. | ||
Soprano II, bar 31 in Legge, 179 in Carus: the second and the third notes are E and C# in Legge, respectively, while they are C# and B natural in Carus. | Soprano II, bar 31 in Legge, 179 in Carus: the second and the third notes are E and C# in Legge/Chrysander, respectively, while they are C# and B natural in Carus. | ||
Alto, bar 27 in Legge, 175 in Carus: the first two notes are G in Legge, E in Carus. | Alto, bar 27 in Legge, 175 in Carus: the first two notes are G in Legge/Chrysander, E in Carus. | ||
Tenor, bar 32 in Legge, 180 in Carus: the | Tenor, bar 32 in Legge, 180 in Carus: the eighth note is E in Legge, D in Carus/Chrysander. | ||
Tenor, bar 41 in Legge, 189 in Carus: the second note is F in Legge, C in Carus. | Tenor, bar 41 in Legge, 189 in Carus: the second note is F in Legge/Chrysander, C in Carus. | ||
Tenor, bar 53 in Legge, 201 in Carus: the last note is F in Legge, A in Carus. | Tenor, bar 53 in Legge, 201 in Carus: the last note is F in Legge/Chrysander, A in Carus. | ||
'''Conquassabit''' | '''Conquassabit''' | ||
Soprano I, bar 45 in Legge, 254 in Carus: the last 5 notes are one third higher in Legge than in Carus. | Soprano I, bar 45 in Legge, 254 in Carus: the last 5 notes are one third higher in Legge than in Carus/Chrysander. | ||
Alto, bar 7 – 8 in Legge, 216 – 217 in Carus: the sequence of notes (all crotchets) is F, D, B | Alto, bar 7 – 8 in Legge, 216 – 217 in Carus: the sequence of notes (all crotchets) is F, D, B{{flat}} (bar 7, 216) and again F, D, B{{flat}} (bar 8, 217) in Carus, while Legge/Chrysander has all F. | ||
Alto, bar 32 in Legge, 241 in Carus: the third note is F# in Legge, F natural in Carus. | Alto, bar 32 in Legge, 241 in Carus: the third note is F# in Legge, F natural in Carus. (The third note is G, the fourth is F# in Chrysander - is this the right bar? I haven't checked any of the last movement.) | ||
Tenor, bar 9 in Legge, 218 in Carus: the last note is A in Legge, F in Carus. | Tenor, bar 9 in Legge, 218 in Carus: the last note is A in Legge/Chrysander, F in Carus. | ||
Line 60: | Line 62: | ||
Soprano I, bar 164: the fourth note is F in Legge, F# in Carus. | Soprano I, bar 164: the fourth note is F in Legge, F# in Carus. | ||
Soprano II, bar 31: the tenth note is D in Legge, B | Soprano II, bar 31: the tenth note is D in Legge, B{{flat}} in Carus. | ||
Soprano II, bar 84: the fifth note is A in Legge, B | Soprano II, bar 84: the fifth note is A in Legge, B{{flat}} in Carus. | ||
Alto, bar 26: the last note is A in Legge, D in Carus. | Alto, bar 26: the last note is A in Legge, D in Carus. | ||
Alto, bar 37: the last six notes are G in Legge, B | Alto, bar 37: the last six notes are G in Legge, B{{flat}} in Carus. | ||
Alto, bar 84: the last note is | Alto, bar 84: the last note is E{{flat}} in Legge, E natural in Carus. | ||
Alto, bar 109: the first note is B | Alto, bar 109: the first note is B{{flat}} in Legge, A in Carus. | ||
Alto, bar 165: the second note is F in Legge, F# in Carus. | Alto, bar 165: the second note is F in Legge, F# in Carus. | ||
Tenor, bar 97: the last two notes ( | Tenor, bar 97: the last two notes (E{{flat}}) are crotchets in Legge, quavers in Carus. A quarter rest completes the bar in Carus. | ||
Tenor, bar 119: the second note (C, dotted crotchet) in Legge is divided into a crotchet plus a quaver in Carus. | Tenor, bar 119: the second note (C, dotted crotchet) in Legge is divided into a crotchet plus a quaver in Carus. | ||
Tenor, bar 127 - 128: the last note of bar 127 and the first note of bar 128 (both | Tenor, bar 127 - 128: the last note of bar 127 and the first note of bar 128 (both B{{flat}}, crotchets) are tied in Carus, while they are not in Legge. | ||
Tenor, bar 135: the last note is B | Tenor, bar 135: the last note is B{{flat}} in Legge, D in Carus. | ||
Bass, bar 170: the sixth and the seventh note are C in Legge, D in Carus. | Bass, bar 170: the sixth and the seventh note are C in Legge, D in Carus. | ||
Bass, bar 171: the second and the third note are B | Bass, bar 171: the second and the third note are B{{flat}} in Legge, D in Carus. The fifth note is B{{flat}} in Legge, A in Carus. | ||
:Comparison made by Max a.k.a. --[[User:Choralia|Choralia]] 18:20, 28 November 2009 (UTC) | :Comparison made by Max a.k.a. --[[User:Choralia|Choralia]] 18:20, 28 November 2009 (UTC) |
Revision as of 00:01, 29 November 2009
A comparison was made between this CPDL edition by Philip Legge (great work, Philip, thank you very much) and a commercial vocal score (Carus Verlag CV 55.232/05). The comparison was limited to the choral parts, without considering the lyrics. The following differences were identified (most of them, or even all, may be editorial).
- My score is based on Chrysander's edition, so I will note where there are discrepancies.
Dixit Dominus
Bass, bar 21: the first note is D in Legge, B♭ in Carus. (Chrysander has B♭, so I will correct this.)
Bass, bar 91: the last note is D in Legge/Chrysander, A in Carus.
Juravit Dominus
Soprano I, bar 22: the first note is F natural in Legge/Chrysander, A♭ in Carus. (Carus seems to be following the Violin 1 part verbatim.)
Soprano I and Soprano II, bar 45 – 46: ties across barline missing in Legge.
Tenor, bar 35: the last note is C in Legge, D in Carus. (Chrysander definitely has C, but perhaps should have D as in Viola 2 part.)
Tu es sacerdos
Soprano II, bar 22: all notes are one third higher in Legge/Chrysander than in Carus. (Carus is following the Violin 2 part.)
Dominus a dextris tuis
Tenor, bar 93: the last note is B♭ in Legge, F in Carus/Chrysander.
Tenor, bar 124: the last note is E in Legge/Chrysander, A in Carus.
Judicabit
Soprano I, bar 57 in Legge, 205 in Carus: the second note is C in Legge/Chrysander, B natural in Carus.
Soprano II, bar 31 in Legge, 179 in Carus: the second and the third notes are E and C# in Legge/Chrysander, respectively, while they are C# and B natural in Carus.
Alto, bar 27 in Legge, 175 in Carus: the first two notes are G in Legge/Chrysander, E in Carus.
Tenor, bar 32 in Legge, 180 in Carus: the eighth note is E in Legge, D in Carus/Chrysander.
Tenor, bar 41 in Legge, 189 in Carus: the second note is F in Legge/Chrysander, C in Carus.
Tenor, bar 53 in Legge, 201 in Carus: the last note is F in Legge/Chrysander, A in Carus.
Conquassabit
Soprano I, bar 45 in Legge, 254 in Carus: the last 5 notes are one third higher in Legge than in Carus/Chrysander.
Alto, bar 7 – 8 in Legge, 216 – 217 in Carus: the sequence of notes (all crotchets) is F, D, B♭ (bar 7, 216) and again F, D, B♭ (bar 8, 217) in Carus, while Legge/Chrysander has all F.
Alto, bar 32 in Legge, 241 in Carus: the third note is F# in Legge, F natural in Carus. (The third note is G, the fourth is F# in Chrysander - is this the right bar? I haven't checked any of the last movement.)
Tenor, bar 9 in Legge, 218 in Carus: the last note is A in Legge/Chrysander, F in Carus.
Gloria Patri
Soprano I, bar 164: the fourth note is F in Legge, F# in Carus.
Soprano II, bar 31: the tenth note is D in Legge, B♭ in Carus.
Soprano II, bar 84: the fifth note is A in Legge, B♭ in Carus.
Alto, bar 26: the last note is A in Legge, D in Carus.
Alto, bar 37: the last six notes are G in Legge, B♭ in Carus.
Alto, bar 84: the last note is E♭ in Legge, E natural in Carus.
Alto, bar 109: the first note is B♭ in Legge, A in Carus.
Alto, bar 165: the second note is F in Legge, F# in Carus.
Tenor, bar 97: the last two notes (E♭) are crotchets in Legge, quavers in Carus. A quarter rest completes the bar in Carus.
Tenor, bar 119: the second note (C, dotted crotchet) in Legge is divided into a crotchet plus a quaver in Carus.
Tenor, bar 127 - 128: the last note of bar 127 and the first note of bar 128 (both B♭, crotchets) are tied in Carus, while they are not in Legge.
Tenor, bar 135: the last note is B♭ in Legge, D in Carus.
Bass, bar 170: the sixth and the seventh note are C in Legge, D in Carus.
Bass, bar 171: the second and the third note are B♭ in Legge, D in Carus. The fifth note is B♭ in Legge, A in Carus.
- Comparison made by Max a.k.a. --Choralia 18:20, 28 November 2009 (UTC)