Talk:Komm, Gott Schöpfer, BWV 370 (Johann Sebastian Bach)
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Merge Pages? BWV?
This year's pentecost is near. When looking for something appropriate to sing, the user finds the current page Komm,_Gott_Schöpfer_(Johann_Sebastian_Bach) and also the page Discendi_Santo_Spirito_(Johann_Sebastian_Bach).
These two works look the same to me. There are only slight differences: the latter sheet is translated into Italian and transposed, i.e. one note lowered. (I hope this is the correct English term.)
- Shouldn't these two pages be merged? Or at least cross-linked?
- Can someone confirm the BWV number 370? (Then this should be mentioned on the current page).
- At least when doing a full text search for Komm, Gott Schöpfer, Heiliger Geist in this Bach database there are two hits only: either BWV 370 (7 verses) or as final chorale of BWV 218 in parts(?) attributed to Telemann). Maybe these two chorales (370 or part5 of 218) are the same?
--PG64 15:55, 16 May 2011 (CDT)